Happy Nursing student

Beyond the 92% Cut-Off: Rethinking Nursing Admissions at McMaster

McMaster Logo
challenge icon

Selecting nursing candidates fairly in a competitive admissions process when grades alone can’t capture essential professional competencies

results icon

Broader access to admission for qualified applicants, improved alignment with nursing competencies, and a more equitable selection process

Bachelor of Nursing

 ~1,500 applicants per year across three collaborative sites

North America – Canada

Challenge

McMaster’s Bachelor of Nursing program is highly competitive, with admission averages rising steadily over time. While academic performance remained important, admissions leaders recognized that grades alone could not fully reflect the qualities it takes to be a great nurse.

The program needed to address several challenges:

  • Admissions decisions relied almost entirely on academic averages, leaving little room to assess non-academic strengths
  • Highly qualified applicants with slightly lower grades had limited opportunities to demonstrate readiness to practice nursing
  • Faculty and staff sought a fairer way to assess competencies such as empathy, ethics, communication, resilience, and collaboration
  • The program needed an approach that aligned admissions decisions with professional nursing standards in Ontario

McMaster required a solution that could support large applicant volumes while expanding the definition of merit beyond grades.

Solution

McMaster University’s School of Nursing adopted Casper to introduce structured, non-academic assessment into its admissions process, tailored specifically to nursing education.

This enabled the program to strengthen admissions in the following ways:

  • Engages faculty across all three sites in blueprinting exercises to identify core nursing characteristics
  • Narrows an initial list of competencies to a focused set aligned with entry-to-practice expectations
  • Uses realistic, profession-relevant scenarios to evaluate applicants’ judgment, ethics, communication, and empathy
  • Applies standardized scoring supported by multiple independent raters
  • Considers Casper scores alongside academic averages, with a minimum academic threshold
  • Creates opportunities for strong candidates to demonstrate readiness beyond grades alone
  • Offers multiple test dates and time slots to accommodate applicants across schedules and time zones

Ola Lunyk-Child
MScN, Assistant and Teaching Professor, McMaster School of Nursing

“We were very pleased this year to have many more applicants below the 92 percent cut-off of last year get accepted because their Acuity Insights Casper score pulled them up.”

Results

Through a more holistic admissions approach, McMaster University’s School of Nursing strengthened fairness, broadened access, and better aligned selection decisions with the realities of nursing education and practice.

The program observed several outcomes:

  • More applicants below previous grade cut-offs received offers based on strong Casper performance
  • Improved alignment between admissions decisions and nursing competencies defined by the College of Nurses of Ontario
  • Positive applicant and parent response to the inclusion of criteria beyond grades
  • Consistent applicant volumes, indicating Casper did not deter qualified candidates

Insights for Higher Ed Leaders

Get updates on admissions research, institutional success stories, and events you won’t want to miss, all in one monthly email.